Here are some interesting words from Dr. Peter Kwasniewski, author of a book I highly recommend: Noble Beauty, Transcendent Holiness. On Facebook he laid out some interesting thoughts:
I'm going to say something that's been on my mind for a long time.
Thomas Aquinas College, which I attended from 1990-1994, the alma mater of countless friends of mine and now their children, is a strange place, because at its heart is a fundamental inconsistency.
They study the Great Books, but they are not devoted to the Great Liturgy, which is the greatest work of art, theology, and culture ever produced in the bosom of the Christian West. They read the best that has been thought and said, but do not pray -- as a rule and as a community -- with the best that has been prayed and sung. In other words, their intellectual life is basically out of step with their Catholic life. In regard to the former, their pinnacle is St. Thomas Aquinas of the 13th century golden age; in regard to the latter, they are firmly post-Vatican II neoconservatives.
If the principles of the Blue Book were well understood and consistently applied, TAC would by now be a booming traditionalist mecca, a sort of counter-Vatican producing fully coherent Catholics.
As it is, TAC graduates too often fall into the trap of urbane intellectualism -- whose current poster child is their beloved Bishop Barron -- because they have not been taught and shown what is more elementary than any book, theory, or doctrine: the total embodiment of Catholicism in her central act of divine worship as matured over 3,000 years of Jewish, Christian, Greco-Roman, and Frankish-Germanic civilization.
𝘛𝘩𝘪𝘴 is the axis around which Christendom formed and revolved, not Aristotle, not Scholasticism, not Trent, not Papal Infallibility. Until we plant this axis firmly in our own minds and hearts 𝘢𝘯𝘥 in our institutions, we are dreaming if we think we will "fix the world." At best, we will create more or less secure ghettos for leading a reasonably sane moral life. That's a good thing, but it's a very partial thing, and has all the marks of a losing rearguard action.
The life and energy in Catholicism are in the traditional movement. When will TAC wake up to this fact and throw their not inconsiderable weight behind it, while allowing themselves to be humbly reintegrated into the great tradition?
If nothing else, Dr. K is arguing here for consistency at Catholic colleges (and I mean the truly Catholic colleges). You can’t claim to be steeped in the Catholic intellectual tradition of the Church, but then worship (which is the central act to all we do) using a Mass formed by a 1960s committee. It is rather schizophrenic.
I could say much about Dr. K’s thoughts and my own experience with Our Lady Seat of Wisdom College in Barry’s Bay, ON. However, I need more time to think things through. A quick answer would be to say that Seat of Wisdom, though a Catholic liberal arts college, does not claim the same degree of intellectual traditional study as St. Thomas Aquinas College in California. Traditional study? Yes. Great Books traditional study? Somewhat, but at least not as the founding principle. Not to say that lets Seat of Wisdom College off the hook.
One final note, I know a couple who went to St. Thomas Aquinas College in California, and it is there that they fell in love with the traditional Latin Mass. Perhaps the TLM is not the main show of TAC (just as the TLM is often pushed to the side when it is at a Novus Ordo parish), but, according to them, it certainly was available. However, being available, and making it at the heart of one’s college, are clearly not the same.
Photo credit: Lifesitenews.ca
Popular posts from this blog
An update of my thoughts on Exodus 90 can be found HERE . Exodus 90 is underway for many Catholic men. It is an intense 90 day program based on prayer, asceticism, and fraternity. For 90 days these men will take cold showers, abstain from alcohol and most media, fast twice per week, give up snacks and desserts, along with various other spiritual tasks. I applaud such a penitential spirit. The inevitable…. HOWEVER… However, I do have two concerns about Exodus 90 which could use some explaining. 1: Sundays The Church already has a wise, if not perfect, system of fasting and feasting. Catholics are encouraged to do penance on Wednesdays and Fridays (some add in Saturdays as well). In addition, there are specific periods of penance (Lent, Advent, Ember Days). Feasting occurs on Sundays as well as on major Feast Days and Solemnities (e.g. the Assumption of Mary). There is a built in balance to life. My problem with Exodus 90 is that, from what I hear, Sundays and F
There is always a certain amount of fear and trembling when I begin writing a piece on a somewhat unfamiliar subject. Perhaps all that will be demonstrated here is my ignorance and incompetence. To which I suppose my wife would reply: “You’d think you’d be used to that by now.” But I write this piece simply for the fact that Catholic trends, even good ones, need sober reflection and refinement. I refer to the Exodus 90 program. [i] Earlier in 2020 – simpler times to be sure - I listened with interest to a podcast on Exodus 90. In it I heard that this program, which was founded in 2013, is an intense 90 day program based on prayer, asceticism, and fraternity. For 90 days men take cold showers, abstain from alcohol and most media, fast twice per week, give up snacks and desserts, meet weekly with a small group of participants, exercise regularly, all the while following a regimented prayer schedule. I applaud such a penitential spirit (though it seems that cold showers in the de
951 Songs/Psalms/Commentaries $17.09 USD Oregon Catholic Press Every now and then a book comes along which is rich in wisdom and beauty, and profoundly enlightening to all who encounter it. The latest Breaking Bread 2021 hymnal is not one of those books. Tiresome, inane, fluffy, fruity, and worthless are all words that come to mind when I consider the latest liturgical offering from our bishops. 2020 was a rough year. 2021 is already off to a mortifyingly awful start. Enough with the suspense. Let's dive into it. Behold a few examples of what to expect at a church near you in 2021: At first I misread this title and thought it was Guns & Roses with Knocking on Heaven's Door. And then I thought of Paul McCartney singing "Someone's knocking at the door...." Sadly, it is neither. I love the juxtaposition though. "Somebody's knock-in' at your door," versus the Stabat Mater . I can just see the choir director, "Hmm... shall we meditate on t
Mark Twain once mused that “all you need in this life is ignorance and confidence, and then success is sure.” These seem like fitting words to begin as I, quivering with emotion, scribe a few words on the death of the fictional (and yet real) Susan from the Parish Council . Her ignorance was inestimable, her confidence impenetrable, and her success undeniable. Not that I can confirm Susan has indeed passed from this life to her eternal… reward. To further cite Twain, perhaps reports of her death have been greatly exaggerated. I suppose Susan can rise from any alleged demise. Truth be told, if Susan is not cremated first, I imagine her funeral as such, with the priest requesting additional “ministers” of Holy Communion, and Susan rising from the casket to pump the Purell and serve Jesus to all her sisters and brothers. But for now, I will dare to speak of Susan as having died. Her online “group newsletter” via Facebook/Twitter has gone silent. She warned recently she was sick
The following is a talk I recently gave at a Catholic men's group: Let’s begin by examining the secular “wokeness” on fasting. Gone are the days of weight loss programs like Weight Watchers… where you simply eat less each meal! Sounds simple, right? Fewer calories means you lose weight. The problem is that it never worked that well. The reduced number of calories per meal also reduced one’s energy as well, dipped into muscle storage, and offered frugal results. Science now shows that full out fasting is the perfect method for proper health. The secular world’s latest trend is intermittent fasting . One builds up how long a person can go in between meals. The ideal is to eat one meal a day. The meal could consist of almost your regular day’s intake (say 75%). What happens is that your body, when full out fasting, actually dips into fat storage for energy. You maintain your energy, lose weight, and it’s perfectly healthy, if not natural. Science shows that intermittent
It is our first full day on our family vacation. After being imprisoned far too long in our little area due to COVID regulations, we are bursting at the seems to traverse and climb the Rocky Mountains. But first, a night in Drumheller, Alberta. The scenery is stunning, yet we are perhaps too excited to see the mountains to give Drumheller its due respects. Also of note, we are a little rusty at camping. It's been a few years since we went on a major trip. This being the first full day, we are disheveled already, and misplacing items left and right. Never mind. It is morning, and before we pack up the campsite I decide to go for a quick jog. I take out my combat rosary , place it on the picnic table at our site, and head out for some exercise throughout the stunning landscape. What a beautiful place. Alas, I return, and our packing up begins in haste. Soon enough we head into the van, eager to hit the highway. Suddenly I slam on the brakes! "Where's my combat rosary!?!"